Skip to content

Menu Engineering: Stars, Plowhorses, Puzzles and Dogs (With Examples)

Menu engineering step by step: the formulas, the 70% rule, a worked euro example for 8 mains and what to do with stars, plowhorses, puzzles and dogs.

A pizza baking in a wood-fired oven, the kind of best-selling dish menu engineering sorts by how often it sells and how much it earns
Photo by Louis Hansel on Unsplash
On this page
  1. What is menu engineering?
  2. The menu engineering formulas
  3. How to do menu engineering in 6 steps
  4. Menu engineering example: 8 mains in a trattoria
  5. The menu engineering matrix: what to do with each group
  6. How one price change moves a plowhorse
  7. Why menu engineering uses prices without VAT
  8. How a digital menu makes menu engineering easier
  9. How do you check that your changes worked?
  10. Common menu engineering mistakes
  11. Menu engineering FAQ
  12. Put your menu engineering into practice today

Menu engineering sorts every dish on your menu by two numbers: how often it sells (menu mix %) and how much it earns per plate (contribution margin = net price − plate cost). Dishes that sell well and earn well are stars, popular low earners are plowhorses, high earners that rarely sell are puzzles, and dishes weak on both are dogs. Each group then gets its own action, so you know which dish to promote, reprice, rework or drop.

Short answer: take one menu section and one month of sales. Spaghetti carbonara sells 310 of 1,365 mains (22.7%) and earns €7.40 per plate (€10.00 net price − €2.60 plate cost). With eight mains, the popularity line is 8.75% and the average margin is €7.23. So carbonara is above both lines, which makes it a star. All figures in this guide are illustrative: use your own sales and costs.

What is menu engineering?

Menu engineering is a method for judging each menu item by its popularity and its contribution margin, so you can decide what to keep, change or remove. The model comes from Kasavana and Smith’s book Menu Engineering: A Practical Guide to Menu Analysis, which a paper in the FIU Hospitality Review describes as “a tool designed to improve managerial effectiveness in pricing, content, design, and marketing strategies.”

The method does not ask which dish has the lowest food cost percentage. Instead, it asks which dishes bring in the most euros overall. That is why a steak with a “bad” food cost can still be one of your best dishes.

The menu engineering formulas

Menu engineering uses five formulas, and every price in them is net of VAT.

  • Contribution margin (CM) = net menu price − plate cost
  • Menu mix % = portions sold of one dish ÷ portions sold in the section × 100
  • Popularity line = (100% ÷ number of dishes in the section) × 70%
  • Average CM = total CM of the section ÷ total portions sold
  • Class: above both lines = star; popular, CM below average = plowhorse; unpopular, CM above average = puzzle; below both = dog

The 70% rule is part of the original model. According to the FIU paper, items with a menu mix “at, or above, 70 percent of average sales” count as popular, and items with an above-average contribution margin count as profitable.

How to do menu engineering in 6 steps

To do menu engineering, pick a section, count sales, work out each dish’s margin, set the two lines and place every dish in the matrix.

Step 1: Pick one section and one period

Analyse one section at a time, such as mains, pizzas or desserts. A dessert will always sell less than a main, so mixing them makes every dessert look like a dog. Then choose a normal period of four weeks or more, without a holiday or a closed week.

Step 2: Count the portions sold

Take the number of portions sold for each dish from your till or ordering system. Count portions, not revenue, because revenue already mixes popularity with price.

Step 3: Work out each dish’s contribution margin

Subtract the plate cost from the net menu price. You need an up-to-date plate cost for each dish, so cost the recipes first with our recipe costing guide. For example, carbonara at €11.00 on the menu is €10.00 net with 10% VAT. With a €2.60 plate cost, its CM is €7.40.

Step 4: Set the popularity line

Divide 100% by the number of dishes and take 70% of the result. With eight mains, each dish’s “fair share” is 12.5%, so the line is 8.75%. A dish with a menu mix of 8.75% or more counts as popular.

Step 5: Set the profit line

Multiply each dish’s CM by its portions sold, add the results and divide by the total portions. This weighted average is the profit line. A simple average of the eight margins would ignore how many of each dish you actually sell.

Step 6: Place each dish in the matrix

Compare each dish with both lines and give it one of the four labels. Then write one action next to each dish before you change anything.

In this example a trattoria sold 1,365 mains in a month and earned €9,862 of contribution margin from them. Prices include 10% VAT, as in Italy, and all figures are illustrative.

DishSoldMenu mixMenu priceNet pricePlate costCMClass
Margherita pizza42030.8%€7.50€6.82€1.64€5.18Plowhorse
Spaghetti carbonara31022.7%€11.00€10.00€2.60€7.40Star
Lasagne26019.0%€12.00€10.91€4.60€6.31Plowhorse
Beef tagliata15011.0%€24.00€21.82€9.80€12.02Star
Grilled sea bass705.1%€22.00€20.00€8.20€11.80Puzzle
Mushroom risotto604.4%€15.00€13.64€3.20€10.44Puzzle
Veal milanese503.7%€16.00€14.55€9.00€5.55Dog
Minestrone453.3%€8.00€7.27€2.40€4.87Dog

The popularity line is 8.75% and the average CM is €9,862 ÷ 1,365 = €7.23. Look at the tagliata: its food cost is about 45%, yet it is a star, because each plate leaves €12.02. In contrast, the pizza has a 24% food cost but earns only €5.18, so it is a plowhorse.

The menu engineering matrix: what to do with each group

Each of the four groups needs a different action, and the aim is always more total margin, not a lower food cost percentage.

  • Stars (popular, high margin): keep the recipe and the portion exactly as they are. Give them the best spot on the menu and a photo, and test small price rises carefully.
  • Plowhorses (popular, low margin): raise the margin without losing the guests. Try a small price rise, a cheaper garnish or a slightly smaller portion, or pair the dish with a high-margin side.
  • Puzzles (unpopular, high margin): help guests notice them. Rewrite the description, move the dish higher in its section, add a photo or ask staff to recommend it. If none of that works, consider a lower price.
  • Dogs (unpopular, low margin): remove them, replace them, or keep one only if it has a clear job, such as the only vegan main.

Treat the matrix as a starting point for questions rather than an automatic verdict. As EHL puts it, it is “most effective as a diagnostic tool, not a checklist for automatic removals or price increases.”

A waiter holding a plate of salad, the kind of high-margin dish staff can recommend to turn a menu engineering puzzle into a star
Photo by Lefteris Kallergis on Unsplash

How one price change moves a plowhorse

A small price rise on a popular dish often adds more margin than any other change on the menu. The table shows the lasagne from the example at three prices, assuming it still sells 260 portions.

Lasagne menu priceNet priceCM per plateSection average CMClassExtra margin per month
€12.00€10.91€6.31€7.23Plowhorse—
€13.00€11.82€7.22€7.40Plowhorse€236.60
€14.00€12.73€8.13€7.57Star€473.20

Sales may of course drop after a price rise. However, even if 10% fewer guests ordered the lasagne at €14.00, 234 plates × €8.13 = €1,902 would still beat the €1,641 it earns today. So test the change for a few weeks, then run the numbers again. For the pricing method itself, see how to price menu items.

Why menu engineering uses prices without VAT

Menu engineering uses net prices because VAT goes to the tax office, not into your margin. Rates also differ by country and between food and drinks, so check yours:

  • Italy: 10% on food and drink served in restaurants (Informazione Fiscale).
  • Germany: 7% on food since 1 January 2026, 19% on drinks (IHK Frankfurt).
  • Spain: 10% on restaurant services and food and drink consumed on the spot (Agencia Tributaria).
  • France: 10% on dishes served in restaurants, 20% on alcoholic drinks (justice.fr).
  • Turkey: 10% on food and drink served by restaurants and cafés, 20% on alcoholic drinks (NTV).

If you analyse drinks, do it in a separate section with their own VAT rate. Our guide on how to price drinks covers pour cost.

How a digital menu makes menu engineering easier

A digital menu turns menu engineering from a yearly project into a monthly habit, because the actions no longer need a reprint. With Elegant Menu, the QR menu and ordering platform, you change a price online and every guest who scans sees it at once. You can also rewrite a puzzle’s description, add a photo or mark a dish as sold out in one tap.

On paid plans, order management and analytics show your best dishes and peak hours, which gives you the sales side of the matrix. Moreover, the menu assistant applies changes you type, such as a price rise on several dishes, and nothing goes live until you approve it. Every dish can also carry all 14 EU allergens as icons, so a reworked recipe keeps its allergen information current.

How do you check that your changes worked?

To check your changes, run the same analysis for the next period and compare the section’s total contribution margin. In the example, the target is to beat €9,862 a month with the same number of covers.

Also compare your theoretical food cost with your real one from stock counts. If the real figure is higher, portions or waste are eating the margin your matrix promised. Our guide to food cost percentage shows the weekly count, and restaurant profit margin shows how the section feeds your bottom line.

Common menu engineering mistakes

Most menu engineering mistakes come from bad inputs or from mixing dishes that should be compared separately.

  1. Mixing sections. Starters, mains and desserts sell in different numbers, so analyse each one on its own.
  2. Using old plate costs. A margin based on last year’s supplier prices puts dishes in the wrong box.
  3. Using prices with VAT. This inflates every margin by the VAT rate and hides the real gap between dishes.
  4. Judging by food cost percentage alone. A high-cost steak can earn more per plate than a cheap pizza.
  5. Changing everything at once. Change a few dishes, wait a full period and measure again.
  6. Dropping every dog. Keep a low seller if it serves a real purpose, such as a vegetarian or children’s option.

What are stars, plowhorses, puzzles and dogs?

They are the four menu engineering groups: stars sell well and earn well, plowhorses sell well but earn little, puzzles earn well but sell little, and dogs do neither.

What is the 70% rule in menu engineering?

The 70% rule says a dish is popular if its menu mix is at least 70% of an equal share. With ten dishes, an equal share is 10%, so the line is 7%.

How often should I do menu engineering?

Do it at least whenever you change the menu, and ideally every month or quarter with fresh sales and costs. A digital menu makes the follow-up changes quick.

Is contribution margin the same as food cost percentage?

No, contribution margin is the euros a dish leaves after its plate cost, while food cost percentage is the share of the price spent on ingredients. Menu engineering ranks dishes by the euros.

Can I do menu engineering in a spreadsheet?

Yes, a spreadsheet with one row per dish and columns for portions sold, net price and plate cost is enough. Add the five formulas above and sort by class.

Put your menu engineering into practice today

Once you know your stars and plowhorses, put the new prices and descriptions on a menu you can change any time. Elegant Menu is free to start, with unlimited scans, 6 categories of 15 dishes each and 20 trial orders a month.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *